00:26 okay good evening folks welcome to our 00:29 second meeting for october 00:33 and uh we'll get the show going 00:38 okay good evening and welcome to the 00:39 regular meeting of the council of the 00:40 city of long beach held tuesday october 00:42 20th 2020 00:43 at 7 p.m weather roll call council 00:45 members lurie president 00:47 councilmember mandel president 00:49 councilmember treston 00:50 president vice president mcginnis 00:52 president 00:53 president bendo present let the record 00:56 indicate the presence of city manager 00:57 donald gaiden corporation council simone 00:59 freeman will have a salute to the flag 01:01 councilman delaurie will you please lead 01:03 us pleasure 01:07 hands over heart i pledge allegiance 01:10 to the flag of the united states of 01:13 america 01:14 and to the republic for which it stands 01:16 one nation 01:18 under god indivisible with liberty and 01:21 justice 01:21 for all 01:28 all right thank you uh so why don't we 01:31 uh start with the city managers report 01:35 uh good evening everyone um to start off 01:39 my report i have commissioner mirando 01:52 good evening can you hear me yes okay 01:56 so uh the city manager asked me to 01:57 report on two items tonight 01:59 uh first is on the potential sale for 02:02 the 02:02 garage property on long beach boulevard 02:05 and as part of that we're looking at 02:08 our transfer station as a place to 02:09 relocate uh we've engaged the burka and 02:12 bartolucci to do a 02:13 uh phase one environmental assessment 02:15 for the site 02:16 and that evaluation will be done 02:21 under the requirements of the american 02:23 standards testing method guidance 02:25 document 02:27 e1527-13 and 02:29 with the appropriate inquiry 02:32 requirements 02:33 in order to complete that phase one they 02:35 will be doing a 02:37 information and document review with 02:39 federal state and local environmental 02:41 database search 02:42 i'll be looking at the fire insurance 02:44 maps aerial photography 02:47 environmental liens and local regulatory 02:49 agency telephone inquiries and foil 02:51 requests 02:52 site inspection will include checking 02:54 for uh any existing storage tanks weight 02:57 stock waste storage areas 02:59 any kind of old transformers drainage 03:01 systems uh 03:03 soil distress vegetation and any kind of 03:05 irregular 03:06 topography uh i've spoke today to them 03:10 we visit the po 03:11 and uh this assessment should be done 03:14 for us by november 6 which will help us 03:16 uh proceed to the next step if we so 03:19 choose to 03:20 relocate the garage there and that's 03:23 item one item two is just a quick update 03:26 on 03:27 edwards boulevard project uh the 03:30 contractor has started his mobilization 03:32 uh bringing in equipment and materials 03:35 and 03:36 the end of this week we'll be starting 03:37 on the drainage portion of the project 03:39 which is the passive drainage system 03:41 that will go in the grass islands 03:43 so it's not drainage that you'll see 03:45 you'll just see basins but they'll be 03:47 very large perforated pipes in the 03:49 ground to take to take ground water 03:52 this project on edwards boulevard and 03:55 coordination with the project that'll be 03:56 coming up shortly on national boulevard 03:59 we'll now have the two main accesses 04:01 down to our board from 04:02 to our boardwalk area from the main uh 04:04 main part of the city uh 04:06 completely redone and will be two nice 04:08 gateways 04:09 down to that portion of the city so 04:12 unless there's any questions that's 04:13 really 04:13 the short report i have tonight uh 04:16 just a quick one john uh in terms of 04:18 doing the uh 04:19 the assessment on the garage property 04:23 uh since while we're at it are they 04:26 gonna do one on the transfer 04:28 yard as well since we probably need to 04:30 know the condition of that or we'll just 04:32 do that 04:32 later that's absolutely we're actually 04:35 doing the 04:35 environment assessment on the transfer 04:37 station property where we would relocate 04:39 the garage 04:41 we are not going to do a environmental 04:43 one on the garage itself 04:44 that would be up to any person who fills 04:48 out an rfp and determines that it might 04:50 uh actually secure the property it would 04:52 be up to the buyer to do that at the 04:54 garage okay 04:55 okay that's fine um 04:58 all right that's all i had anybody else 05:01 got any questions for john 05:05 okay thanks john you're welcome 05:09 the next person speaking is gabriella 05:11 and she is going to talk about 05:13 why so many residents are seeing an 05:15 increase in their water bills 05:26 donna could you could you please uh let 05:29 me know 05:29 uh gabriella's title please 05:36 hello 05:42 yes can you tell your title for the 05:44 water department please 05:46 um supervisor of water billing thank you 05:52 okay you can start go ahead um 05:56 i think it's just come up a lot that you 05:58 know there's an 05:59 increase in the water sewer bills um 06:03 and it's kind of caused concern amongst 06:04 a lot of people but 06:06 it's really boiled down to just 06:09 summertime usage because this is a 06:10 billing cycle that covers 06:12 consumption from the beginning of june 06:14 to the beginning of september 06:16 it is normal to see a decent increase 06:19 during the october billing cycle 06:21 um so this is something that happens 06:23 every single year it's 06:24 not something really out of the ordinary 06:28 there may be a little extra usage due to 06:30 clovid 06:31 um if people are home during the 06:32 pandemic more but 06:34 there is not really cause for concern as 06:36 far as 06:38 something being wrong with the water 06:39 bills which i think has come up 06:41 um or an increase in the prices or 06:44 anything like that 06:54 thank you does anyone have any questions 06:58 um gabriella mike delore was it 07:02 has anybody ever called that 07:05 um was uncovered that they actually had 07:07 a leak 07:08 or it's you just can't determine that 07:12 no sure of course there are people that 07:13 have leaks um if there's something 07:15 abnormally high you know i can't reach 07:17 out to people during the month 07:18 that we do the meter readings which 07:21 would have been like in september 07:22 if i see something that's unusually high 07:25 i 07:25 try and reach out to a resident to let 07:27 them know that there might be something 07:28 going on and 07:29 yes there are times that it could be due 07:31 to a leak however i will say 07:33 that more frequently during this billing 07:36 cycle a lot of 07:38 extra usage is because of the summertime 07:41 month 07:42 thank you 07:47 anyone else got any questions 07:50 no thank you gabriella okay thank you 07:54 gabriella 07:57 okay next we have mr mcnally 08:02 good evening everybody just a few quick 08:04 items that the city manager asked me to 08:06 speak on 08:07 uh number one wanted to reiterate what 08:09 was announced at the working meeting 08:11 this past 08:12 thursday that hours for the boardwalk in 08:15 the beach 08:15 uh the restrictions thereof have been 08:17 lifted 08:18 um so we are back to the boardwalk and 08:21 the beach being open until 11 08:23 p.m for anyone who wishes to still be 08:24 there at 11 pm 08:26 uh those were all part of an executive 08:29 order 08:30 related to covid so if the situation on 08:33 the ground warns it in the future 08:35 that obviously could be reinstated uh 08:38 and just so everyone is aware uh 08:40 with respect to covid throughout almost 08:42 the entire supper months our 08:45 seven day rolling single day average so 08:47 smoothed out average over a seven day 08:49 period four 08:51 number of positive cases detected within 08:53 the city's boundaries 08:55 for a single day hover anywhere between 08:58 half of the confirmed case or positive 09:00 test case to one 09:02 for the past three weeks i would say or 09:04 two weeks 09:06 we're now over two confirmed cases a day 09:09 on our 09:09 seven-day rolling average so that's by 09:12 no means a spike 09:13 it's nowhere near where we were in the 09:15 springtime um 09:17 but the numbers are starting to nudge 09:19 the way upwards 09:20 that's not the metric that the state 09:23 necessarily uses they use 09:25 positivity rate so all of those tested 09:28 what percentage of those tested 09:29 have tested positive but we don't have 09:31 access to that data 09:33 so this is really the only data that we 09:34 have on our level to really keep an eye 09:36 out 09:37 so we will continue to remind our 09:39 residents to wear masks social distance 09:42 stay home when you can and wash your 09:44 hands thoroughly 09:45 and frequently number two that city 09:48 manager asked me to speak about was the 09:50 bike lanes on broadway 09:52 they started doing some of the 09:54 preliminary work for 09:56 really just restriping and replacing the 09:58 the bike lane that existed on 10:00 both the north and south side of 10:02 broadway 10:03 they started that preliminary work but 10:05 we are also doing 10:07 some uh resurfacing on certain stretches 10:10 of broadway so we're working to 10:12 coordinate those two projects so that 10:14 we're not putting down bike lanes and 10:15 then repaving over them 10:18 the departments between the police 10:19 department and dpw and street 10:20 maintenance are doing a good job with 10:22 that coordination 10:23 we anticipate that within two weeks all 10:25 of the resurfacing projects will be done 10:28 and the dedicated bike lane will be 10:32 reinstalled and re-striped on broadway 10:34 and that does include some sharings but 10:35 they're doing the dedicated bi-plane 10:37 with 10:38 uh full stripes both on the north side 10:40 and the south side of broadway 10:42 the third announcement to make was as of 10:46 i want to say around 10 30 a.m today 10:49 we have successfully put out an rfp for 10:52 electronic beach past sales so 10:56 we're we're looking for thank you karen 10:58 even though you're muted your enthusiasm 11:00 left right off 11:02 uh we're looking for a response um from 11:04 responsible parties within the next 11:06 month or so we left it i think general 11:09 enough so that we could get a variety of 11:12 solutions pitch to us because there's 11:14 quite frankly not that many companies 11:16 out there that do this so we didn't want 11:18 to make it so restrictive 11:20 uh that would be boxing out potential 11:22 vendors 11:23 uh so that's exciting and we're hoping 11:26 to 11:27 really sign a contract if everything 11:28 goes according to plan sometime 11:30 early in the new year and lastly just to 11:33 remind 11:34 everybody that our collaboration and 11:36 partnership with 11:38 the chamber of commerce and the arts 11:40 council for beyond the beach our 11:42 city-wide fall celebration is this 11:44 weekend from friday saturday sunday 11:46 we've got over 30 houses that have 11:48 signed up for the house decorating 11:50 contest 11:50 and over 50 businesses that have either 11:53 signed up for 11:54 storefront decoration or to offer uh 11:57 discounts or incentives for their 11:59 respective businesses so we've got 12:01 really good buy-in for our first year we 12:02 think it's going to be really fun 12:03 weather 12:04 a really fun you know event we're 12:06 praying for good weather 12:08 um and you know look forward to this 12:10 being the start of a really good 12:11 tradition moving forward 12:13 so those are my four items any questions 12:17 uh yeah for the beyond the beach uh 12:20 the rumor was there was going to be a 12:22 map online so people 12:24 would be able to know what businesses 12:26 and 12:27 were participating what houses would 12:29 being decorated and stuff 12:30 how would people find that you bet so 12:33 that's going to be both on the city's 12:34 website 12:35 and on the chambers website we have a 12:36 call tomorrow but i anticipate it going 12:39 live 12:39 no later than thursday i've already seen 12:42 the drafts of it it's going to be 12:44 either a pdf picture that you can access 12:47 or 12:48 there's a google map version of it so 12:50 you can just bring it up on your phone 12:51 and as you're traversing the city 12:53 you can see where the next closest house 12:55 or business is that's participating in 12:57 the event 12:58 okay and just so people are clear 13:02 this is sort of like a halloween 13:04 celebration thing people are going to be 13:05 decorating their houses for halloween 13:08 um and some people are really kind of 13:11 taking this thing to the 13:12 to the to the extreme that's that's the 13:15 hope and that's what we're going for 13:16 like i said we have 30 13:17 homeowner entries or you know 13:19 residential entries 13:21 i've seen a couple of them in my travels 13:22 already and there are some really good 13:24 ones out there 13:25 and again this is this is a tradition 13:27 that we hope grows over the years 13:29 but also you know brings a little fun in 13:31 what's been a rather difficult summer 13:34 and helps drive a little bit of business 13:36 to our local you know commerce 13:38 uh for because they've obviously 13:40 experienced a rather difficult summer as 13:41 well so hopefully giving them a little 13:43 bit of boost in the arm heading into the 13:44 winter 13:46 okay great anybody else got any 13:49 questions for john 13:50 um i just want to say what uh you know 13:53 to john and to the chamber 13:55 um really appreciate the city 13:57 partnership with the chamber 13:58 to come up with new and innovative ideas 14:01 for um 14:02 for businesses here and for the 14:03 residents i thought it was there's a lot 14:05 of hard work that's going on beyond 14:07 behind the scenes because i see all the 14:09 emails 14:10 um so i just want want everyone to know 14:13 it's really appreciated and 14:14 it doesn't go unnoticed so thank you 14:16 very much thank you for that the the 14:18 chamber and the arts council have really 14:20 done 14:20 an outstanding job you know these are 14:22 these are volunteer organizations and 14:24 the chamber is taking on a 14:25 yeoman's portion of this work uh we 14:27 should note obviously that their website 14:29 is the long beachchamber.com 14:32 and that's where all of the event 14:33 information is and that's you know where 14:34 the map will go up as well in addition 14:36 to 14:37 our facebook page and our website thanks 14:40 thanks to everyone yeah i'm john and i 14:43 did the website the information that's 14:45 put out there 14:46 by the chamber and and members and web 14:50 designers whoever 14:51 they did a fabulous job and i could say 14:53 there's a 14:54 must have been a lot of work that went 14:56 into doing this you know 14:58 very detailed now abs 15:01 absolutely and again a lion shared a bit 15:04 is done by the chamber 15:05 um in conjunction with the arts council 15:07 and the city played its role but 15:08 um hats off to them they really made 15:10 this happen and did you know vast 15:12 majority of the work and they are all 15:14 volunteer board members but they all 15:16 dove right into this 15:17 um so kudos to them 15:21 thank you okay who's in the batter's box 15:30 ah commissioner ragona okay 15:40 hi good evening everybody can you hear 15:42 me yes yep 15:45 still the same as the phone number 15:48 i'm sorry no i'm asking dave a question 15:50 because there's a phone number 15:52 is that scott that's me i was uh booted 15:55 off so i'm on by phone 15:57 okay 16:00 sorry sorry commissioner please continue 16:03 no no problem um the city manager asked 16:06 me to speak about a topic which has come 16:08 across my desk 16:09 numerous times in the last week and um 16:12 and i'll be brief 16:14 however it's uh it's important to a lot 16:16 of our residents and 16:17 it involves bicycles so mr mcnally uh 16:21 touched on it earlier 16:23 in regards to the bike lanes which are 16:26 very important to our residents 16:27 and we have uh secured a grant through 16:31 um patty bourne thank you and tyler over 16:34 an economic development 16:36 um working with them to restripe the 16:39 bike lanes 16:40 uh along broadway broadway is probably 16:43 the 16:44 not probably it is the best um 16:47 location in the city to have our bike 16:50 lanes 16:50 it runs through a significant part of 16:53 the town 16:54 to our city it runs from new york avenue 16:56 down to maple 16:57 um uninterrupted and so we 17:01 we started striping and we're 17:02 coordinating with public works 17:04 um as uh john miranda said earlier 17:08 they're uh doing overlay in asheville's 17:11 overlay 17:11 uh off from long beach boulevard to 17:13 roosevelt boulevard 17:14 um right now so we're working with them 17:18 as far as putting down the striping um 17:22 currently we're putting shadows down and 17:24 then we'll be striping the whole bike 17:26 lane 17:26 in accordance with the uh uh the uniform 17:29 guard 17:30 for uh for traffic uh 17:33 direction that we need to do um 17:36 i've reached out to our local um bicycle 17:40 enthusiasts who are 17:41 experts and who are of great help to us 17:45 and we'll be coordinating with them as 17:47 we progress over the next two weeks 17:49 doing our bicycle lanes from new york to 17:51 maple 17:52 both north and south of um broadway 17:56 on both sides it's uh it's something 17:59 that 17:59 we need and that our residents want so 18:02 as far as that goes 18:03 we should be done in approximately two 18:05 weeks if everything goes as expected 18:08 and um it'll be done according to the 18:12 way that it should 18:12 uh be done 18:16 secondly i've had a number of calls 18:19 about the 18:20 abandoned bicycles in town and in the 18:22 city uh 18:23 specifically the long island railroad so 18:26 we went down there and there 18:27 uh there were 102 bicycles that had a 18:30 park there 18:31 from uh the east and west side of the 18:33 rail 18:34 uh most of them seem to be moved daily 18:37 probably 10 to 15 18:39 of them in my opinion and i was down 18:40 there uh 18:42 on not being moved regularly so we've 18:45 uh we put warning tags on them and the 18:47 next two days 18:49 uh they're in violation of a miscible 18:50 code if they just leave their bike staff 18:53 we'll be uh taking them we'll unlock the 18:56 locks 18:57 we'll take them with us and we'll put 18:59 them on our impound lot and we'll leave 19:00 them there 19:01 um until someone comes to claim it 19:04 but uh we can't have abandoned bicycles 19:07 all over the 19:08 long island railroad so we're in the 19:10 process of doing that also 19:12 and that's really been my big complaint 19:13 this week has been the 19:15 bicycle issues from the uh striping for 19:17 the bike lanes 19:19 and the abandoned bicycles down to long 19:20 island railroad 19:23 thank you 19:26 all right anybody got any questions uh 19:29 for phil 19:32 all right thanks phil appreciate it 19:36 all right next person up is councilwoman 19:38 trusted 19:40 oh thank you i just want to make sure 19:43 everyone is still aware 19:45 that the nassau county hazard mitigation 19:47 plan 19:48 their comment period ends at the end of 19:51 this month 19:52 so visit their website which is 19:57 going on nassau county ny 20:00 dot gov and then just uh 20:04 doing a search to find oem the emergency 20:07 management home page 20:08 and if you want to comment please do so 20:11 thank you 20:16 okay thanks and anything else the last 20:20 thing is 20:20 for everyone that applied to the boards 20:23 and the commissions i say thank you 20:25 we are in the process um we have several 20:27 applications 20:28 we are still interviewing and those that 20:31 applied should start 20:32 hearing from us by the end of this week 20:35 beginning of next week 20:37 that completes my report 20:40 okay uh anybody else got any questions 20:44 for anybody all right 20:48 then let's move on okay on to the agenda 20:51 first items approval of minutes for 20:52 prior meetings september 1st 20:54 through uh sorry and september 15 2020. 21:02 sorry i hit the mute yeah yeah sorry i 21:06 i i hit the hit the button by mistake uh 21:08 who'll make a motion to approve 21:10 i will second i will 21:15 morning councilmember de laurie uh yes 21:17 councilman randall 21:19 yes councilmember treston yes vice 21:22 president mcginnis 21:24 yes president pando yes 21:27 okay item choose a resolution 21:29 authorizing the city manager to amend 21:30 the agreement for architectural 21:32 engineering design services for the city 21:34 of long beach bulkheading 21:35 northshore project and to amend the 21:36 budget 21:39 and i'm going to guess that's our mr 21:41 mirando 21:42 again that's correct 21:50 did i on mute yes okay um 21:53 so back in 2015 we signed a 21:57 professional services contract for 21:59 architectural engineering design and 22:01 construction administration 22:02 with tetra tech for the north shore 22:04 bulkhead uh 22:06 this is the third request for an 22:08 increase in cost 22:09 these increases have already been 22:11 approved by the governor's office of 22:12 storm recovery 22:14 in the amount of forty three thousand 22:15 ninety nine dollars and thirteen cents 22:18 uh we don't have to lay out any of this 22:20 funds this comes directly from ghosts to 22:22 us and then from us to the contra 22:24 to the engineering firm um this is the 22:27 third uh 22:28 increase in the budget over five-year 22:30 period costs have changed and some of 22:31 the design parameters have changed 22:34 and some of the construction work and 22:35 progress has changed 22:37 so we just need to approve this because 22:39 we're the ones that hold the 22:41 purchase order 22:44 okay um anybody got any questions for 22:47 john 22:51 okay hearing none do we have any 22:53 questions from the public 22:56 i have no hand oh wait we have roy 22:58 lester 23:03 okay roy go ahead whenever you're ready 23:05 go ahead and mute i 23:07 unmuted you can hear me yes okay 23:10 um three times they've asked for 23:13 increases and i'm not sure 23:15 i i understand this is just for 23:16 administration 23:18 and construction inspection now i 23:20 understand if you're doing construction 23:23 costs go up and and things change but 23:26 just on the inspection 23:27 i mean this is it there's not a lot 23:30 that's changing this is just the 23:32 bulkhead 23:33 and it's basically the same as when we 23:36 first started 23:38 um and the administration why 23:41 and i know it's not our money i mean 23:43 it's not the city's money it's 23:45 our money because it's our taxes why are 23:48 these things going up like this 23:50 well the the cost for their their uh 23:53 engineers and 23:54 people that work for them go up in 23:56 addition there's been several change 23:57 orders as things that we 23:59 are that you don't expect when you're 24:01 doing the construction as an example 24:03 would 24:03 we just uh had to approve a 265 24:07 000 change order due to an issue uh 24:10 related to the uh deflection in the 24:12 bulkhead 24:13 as a result of a requirement from the 24:15 new york state dec to place concrete 24:17 between the old bulkhead and the new 24:18 bulkhead 24:19 so that took a whole new redesign and 24:22 additional time for for inspection 24:25 services to see that through 24:28 how much was the original contract um 24:31 you know 24:32 i don't have that in front of me roy but 24:35 do you know how much the 24:36 uh it goes back to 2015 so no i know and 24:39 i tried to look it up and i couldn't get 24:41 it 24:42 and do you know how much the additional 24:44 uh 24:46 the additional funding was for the other 24:49 two times 24:51 uh no i don't have that in front of me 24:52 either all right if i could 24:54 get it at some point yeah thanks a lot 24:56 john give me a call in the office i'll 24:58 have all that right there 24:59 okay thank you okay 25:03 uh any other questions from the public 25:09 you muted dave 25:12 i know that was the only one that i have 25:14 okay then let's move on to item 25:16 three okay item three is a resolution 25:19 authorizing the city manager to enter 25:20 into a contract 25:21 for street lighting maintenance and 25:22 repair with the lowest responsible 25:24 bidder 25:25 and i'm gonna guess that's john again 25:28 correct 25:28 uh so uh our street lighting contract 25:31 has run out with extensions with wells 25:33 back 25:33 as of the end of november we put out a 25:36 new bid 25:38 four vendors picked up contracts uh only 25:41 three bid 25:42 the prices range from 365 910 25:46 to 800 9410 uh 25:49 the winning bid was new york trenchless 25:52 incorporated at 365 25:54 910 dollars uh 25:57 and we did do a significant check on 25:59 their references 26:00 uh with a couple of the towns and the 26:03 new york state d.o.t that they did work 26:04 for 26:05 we've had very good recommendations on 26:07 them a 26:08 portion of this is for normal monthly 26:11 maintenance 26:12 uh the monthly maintenance charge from 26:14 what we were paying will drop from 15 26:16 000 a month to 7 000 a month that's a 26:18 significant savings 26:20 uh the additional money in the contract 26:23 is for 26:24 is based on estimated repairs to 26:27 underground lines and things of that 26:28 nature 26:29 so this is typically we put in the 26:32 amounts that we've experienced over the 26:34 previous 26:34 years so there's a chance that we may 26:36 not spend any of that because 26:38 at the same time this contract is going 26:40 out uh we have a grant by niper 26:42 to finish replacing um 26:46 all of our non-led lights which is about 26:48 another 700 lights 26:50 and in addition they'll be adding a uh 26:53 monitoring program that will 26:54 automatically 26:55 uh send a text to us or a email when 26:59 it's 26:59 just typical when a street light goes 27:01 out before 27:03 we hear from even a resident so um i 27:05 think we'll be saving a significant 27:07 amount of money over the next 27:08 two years with this contract 27:11 okay um well actually i'll stop okay uh 27:15 john i'm going 27:16 i'm going from memory here but wells 27:18 bach we were paying them about 27:20 15 grand a month right correct all right 27:22 so this is basically a wash so this is 27:24 about the same price as we were paying 27:26 wells by 27:27 no no no they this their monthly 27:29 maintenance fee is only uh 7 000 a month 27:31 oh i'm sorry i'm sorry that's right 27:33 savings of 8 27:34 000 a month that's true i'm sorry 27:35 because you said the difference was 27:37 for anticipated repairs all right 27:40 so um anybody else got any questions 27:44 um i have one john um commissioner was 27:47 mike delore 27:48 um did wells back bid on this portion 27:52 again yes they did their bid came in 27:54 significantly higher than it was last 27:56 time their bid came in at 571 thousand 27:59 dollars 28:00 yeah and um i 28:04 these i guess the smart technology or 28:06 that 28:07 the question or the comment that you 28:09 made about the ability to find out 28:13 if a street light goes out before a 28:16 resident may call 28:19 right that's not part of this contract 28:20 that's part of the a neighbor grant that 28:22 we have 28:23 that we're presently working on we we 28:26 included that in this contract for 28:27 information for the contractor so they 28:29 know that 28:30 significant change will be coming in 28:32 addition to that which each um 28:35 what nypa does is they actually size the 28:37 wattage that we need 28:39 and as a result when we lower wattage on 28:41 a bulb we don't pay 28:42 metered rates for street lighting we pay 28:45 based on the wattage of each bulb 28:47 uh so each light fixture so by 28:51 properly sizing as we have been when we 28:53 do new street construction properly 28:55 sizing the wattage that we need we're 28:56 reducing the cost that we're paying to 28:58 pse g 29:00 and do you think the fixtures itself 29:03 would have to be replaced to match 29:05 the newer bulb or the fixtures that we 29:07 have 29:08 currently would fit no some of the the 29:11 uh 29:12 um the gen 29:15 there's there's a uh almost like a 29:16 ballast but it's not a ballast for an 29:18 led it's a kind of a generator in the 29:20 poll 29:20 that is matched to the voltage for the 29:23 light so 29:24 okay thank you 29:28 anyone else yes aaron uh john this is 29:31 karen 29:32 um i just wanted to make sure that you 29:34 and your staff are 29:36 uh comfortable with the exit clauses of 29:38 this contract 29:39 in terms of performance measures if they 29:40 are not met yes 29:43 very good thank you 29:47 hi john this is this is liz um 29:50 just this will have no effect on the 29:53 boardwalk lights and the contracts we 29:54 have with buzzback 29:56 will it no wellspace really wasn't 30:00 contracted to take care of the boardwalk 30:01 lights we took care of them ourselves 30:03 uh what wells back did for us with the 30:05 issue we had in lights which have all 30:07 been replaced 30:08 now with the with the new uh uh fixtures 30:11 uh not too light fishes but the new 30:13 connections uh 30:14 wells back did that directly and was 30:17 paid by sternberg for that 30:19 uh the manufacturer of the light so this 30:21 will have no effect on it but 30:23 this contract does include now this time 30:25 maintenance of those lights 30:26 also on the boardwalk great thank you 30:29 sir 30:34 okay scott you got a question you're the 30:37 only one who didn't ask something you 30:38 may as well come up with something 30:40 i think it's pretty clear-cut okay 30:44 all right so uh any questions from the 30:46 public yes we have roy lester 30:49 okay roy you're on muted god 30:54 okay i'm unmuted god yep 30:57 yeah all right um a couple of questions 30:59 john did you say that 31:01 if they don't have to do as much work 31:04 we don't have to pay that much money or 31:06 is this a fixed fee 31:07 i i wasn't sure i understood that well 31:09 there's a fixed fee for the monthly 31:11 maintenance 31:12 okay which is seven thousand dollars a 31:15 month 31:15 the other i'm sorry john that's that's 31:18 not included in the 365. 31:20 that's that's included no that's 31:22 included in the 365 but that 31:24 amounts to you know eighty four thousand 31:26 dollars right right yeah 31:27 but the rest is what we do is there's 31:30 different kinds of repairs that take 31:31 place 31:32 if you have an underground break there's 31:34 money in there to take care of locating 31:36 where the brake is there's money in 31:37 there to replace underground cable 31:40 uh if a pole is hit there's money there 31:42 to play replace a pole 31:44 and what we we do just to have a basis 31:46 to compare the bids 31:48 is we estimate based on our history over 31:50 the last two or three years how many of 31:52 those underground breaks do we get 31:54 how many poles get hit uh how many 31:56 fixtures 31:57 you know uh not the the uh of itself but 32:00 how many 32:01 arms making it making it real simple 32:04 john 32:04 if we have no underground breaks if we 32:07 get no polls hit do we get money back 32:10 no we don't get money back but we don't 32:11 pay we don't pay we only pay what we use 32:14 it's a requirements contract so the 365 32:18 is the maximum 32:20 the 360 the 365 is the estimate of what 32:23 it would cost us 32:24 estimate okay that's what i wasn't sure 32:28 it's not a it's not a fix 32:30 it's not a hard number no oh okay and 32:33 the other thing is you said we take care 32:34 of the 32:35 well we used to take care of the 32:36 boardwalk lights ourselves 32:38 just out of curiosity how come we don't 32:41 do 32:42 all this work in-house we we don't we 32:45 don't have enough trained electricians 32:46 to do this okay 32:47 i know right brakes and what have you we 32:49 have one electrician that works for 32:51 beach maintenance that's 32:52 it okay and they take right now they 32:55 were taking care of the boardwalk lights 32:57 right one guy 32:58 and we also don't have you know large 33:00 trucks for high 33:01 fixtures and things of that nature you 33:03 know we just have the one boom truck 33:05 all right that answers my question thank 33:07 you john you're welcome 33:11 okay any other questions from the public 33:14 do not see any more hands at this time 33:17 okay 33:18 let's move on to item four and enforce a 33:20 resolution authorizing the city manager 33:22 to accept funds 33:23 from the new york state municipal 33:25 workers compensation alliance 33:28 and that is simone good evening 33:32 so um we are part of the new york state 33:36 municipal compensation 33:37 workers compensation alliance or comp 33:39 alliance 33:40 and they administer our workers 33:43 compensation insurance 33:45 um and various other municipalities 33:48 workers compensation insurance so 33:50 in appreciation of its members and also 33:53 um 33:54 in response to covid they 33:57 um have been issuing loyal member 33:59 loyalty awards 34:01 so we have been issued a member loyalty 34:03 award of 34:04 four thousand seven hundred and eighty 34:06 six dollars 34:08 um that we'd like to accept 34:15 okay they mute anyone that says they 34:17 don't want to accept it okay 34:20 um all right any questions from anyone 34:23 on the council 34:25 uh yes this is karen i have two 34:27 questions for you simone 34:29 yes was this calculation based on the 34:31 fact that our workforce decreased 34:34 well they've been doing we did get a 34:36 previous check and i think that was 34:38 based on the calculation of our 34:39 workforce 34:40 this is something that they review it's 34:42 my understanding 34:43 annually um and it's based on your 34:46 long-term membership and also what your 34:48 claims are and how things have been 34:49 processed so 34:50 in part i think they might be giving a 34:52 little bit more because of code but 34:54 it's a little it's a mix they do do the 34:56 annual loyalty award anyway but 34:59 it's it's slightly a mix i guess if that 35:01 answers your question 35:03 yes yeah if i if i recall correctly they 35:05 gave us back 35:07 twenty thousand dollars last year if i 35:09 remember correctly 35:10 right yeah it's a little bit higher than 35:12 it was last year yeah i think 35:13 that covet is why um it's higher 35:17 um of course because of covet but every 35:19 year you should get money back 35:21 when they have a certain surplus yes 35:24 this 35:24 they had a probably a higher surplus 35:27 this year 35:28 because of coal because of cooling yes 35:31 so then my second question is of course 35:33 i'm all about the savings 35:35 so it's not savings but it's a it's a 35:37 surplus so therefore i'd like to know 35:39 what account 35:40 number this is credited to or what 35:42 account designation 35:44 we'll get that to you because it goes 35:45 back into the general fund 35:47 so we'll send that to you we'll send 35:48 that to the entire council 35:50 to say which account number it goes into 35:52 thank you 35:55 all right anyone else 35:59 all right any questions from the public 36:01 dave yes 36:02 uh we have roy lester once again okay 36:05 roy you're on muted go ahead 36:07 okay um what did we pay last year into 36:10 this uh 36:11 alliance 36:14 roy i'll have to look that up and i'll 36:16 get that back to you 36:17 okay and it it's a it's basically an 36:20 alliance so 36:21 and it's a not-for-profit isn't it yes 36:25 so isn't it doesn't that money the 36:27 surplus belong to the members 36:31 yes the surplus it depends on what their 36:34 bylaws say but a surplus does belong to 36:36 the members 36:37 but they can so it's not an appreciation 36:39 of its membership it's 36:40 it actually belongs to us well that's 36:42 what they 36:43 remember right yeah that's the thing 36:45 okay okay 36:47 and and um is there a formula to this 36:50 to what they do i have no idea what the 36:53 formula is we will have to look at to 36:54 see how they divide 36:56 within their bylaws how they they uh 36:58 determine a surplus 36:59 okay you're welcome thank you thank you 37:04 okay anyone else steve nope that was 37:08 it okay let's move on to item five 37:12 item five is a resolution authorizing 37:13 amendments to the urban development fund 37:15 budget years 37:16 2016 17 18 19 and 20. 37:20 all right that's patty bourne okay 37:31 good evening 37:34 the city's urban development funds are 37:37 comprised 37:38 of the lease payments from stop and shop 37:41 realty inc 37:43 it's based upon the city obtained a 5 37:46 million dollar 37:47 urban development action grant or udag 37:51 grant from hud in the 1980s 37:54 for economic development purposes the 37:57 funds were made available 37:58 to the city to purchase the seven acres 38:01 of the now 38:01 houses the stop and shop retail mall 38:04 where our stop and shop supermarket is 38:08 and um in terms of use 38:11 of the lease funds that come back every 38:14 year 38:14 from stop and shop because they're 38:16 leasing the property 38:17 from the city i had checked with our 38:20 current 38:21 auditors our controller 38:24 ina and our past auditors and the 38:27 guidance for the use of the funds 38:29 was that the city should use them to 38:31 improve the community 38:33 and provide programs that generally meet 38:35 hud 38:36 priorities however there is no 38:39 hud oversight on these funds as the udag 38:44 program ended several decades ago 38:47 and in fact i spoke to someone who used 38:50 to work for hud 38:51 and is knowledgeable and he concurred 38:53 again 38:54 that there is no interest or action from 38:56 hud but we're following the guidance on 38:58 the use of the funds from 39:00 our auditor the amendments being 39:02 considered tonight 39:03 are consistent with prior amendments to 39:06 this fund 39:08 specifically they are to support ada 39:11 work at city hall 39:12 we're going to make improvements to the 39:14 new elevator that's going in 39:16 the second elevator and support for 39:19 community programs 39:21 and staff and one example is the senior 39:23 programs that we 39:25 support that will now be virtual rather 39:28 than in person due to covet 39:30 so there are two actions tonight in the 39:33 resolution the first is to amend the 39:36 2016 39:38 through 2019 fund years to put money 39:43 into contracted services and that total 39:46 will be used 39:47 for the elevator towards the total cost 39:49 of the elevator paid a portion of it 39:51 and that's eligible because ada purpose 39:54 and 39:55 we're also looking to allocate 39:58 the funds for the year 2020 and those 40:01 funds will be used 40:03 for as indicated in the resolution for 40:06 salaries temporary salaries 40:08 and contracted services consistent with 40:11 priority programs 40:18 okay uh any questions from the 40:22 council members 40:26 i would this is karen i would just say 40:28 that i i have no doubt everything is in 40:30 order 40:30 absolutely no doubt about it but i 40:33 didn't really really 40:37 karen you muted yourself 40:41 you still muted you stole me you did 40:44 i did i don't know all right okay 40:48 so like i'll just to recap i have no 40:51 doubt that everything is in order here 40:53 and i really appreciate all the hard 40:54 that work that went into it 40:56 but prior to receiving this packet i 40:59 really had no idea that this fund 41:00 existed 41:01 so i'm not really comfortable in voting 41:03 on this tonight so i would ask that it 41:04 be tabled 41:08 until i can understand what's what's 41:10 what's going on here 41:18 how much are you making a motion or 41:22 thank you john i would like to make a 41:23 motion that we table this 41:25 to uh so that we can get a further 41:27 understanding 41:28 of how the urban development plan has 41:30 been working for the past several years 41:32 please 41:33 okay motion to table do i have a second 41:38 anyone there is there a time 41:42 is this there is there a time crunch on 41:44 this 41:45 that it needs to happen today 41:49 do we are we going to have to have a 41:50 special meeting well well 41:52 the discussion normally comes that's the 41:55 vote i'm sorry 41:56 after not after the vote after somebody 41:58 seconds then there's discussion before 42:00 the vote so 42:04 sorry i'm learning still thank you 42:06 that's okay 42:10 all right is there any second on this 42:14 motion 42:16 all right seeing no second the motion 42:18 fails 42:22 okay uh any other questions 42:28 and then just i guess for information 42:30 purposes for people that may not 42:32 go to city hall why this is kind of 42:35 important where it's going to the 42:36 elevator 42:37 city hall when the building was built 42:40 had three elevators 42:42 uh only one has worked for 42:45 for quite some time one has been out of 42:46 commission since i think since 42:49 for years uh one worked intermittently 42:52 for a while but hasn't worked for a few 42:54 years now so there's only one elevator 42:56 and even that 42:57 breaks down and if uh i know many 42:59 employees and myself included have 43:02 gotten stuck in that one elevator that 43:05 uh dave shaking his head so he got stuck 43:07 last week 43:08 all right he got stuck last week and you 43:10 know you wind up having 43:12 to call sometimes the fire department so 43:14 they can come get you out 43:15 well luckily the elevator repair guys 43:17 were on the state we're on the floor 43:18 below and they were able to get me out 43:20 yeah they had to call the fire 43:22 department for me but uh 43:24 uh so yeah we need we need to get this 43:27 fixed 43:28 uh so we at least have uh one one 43:31 certainly 43:32 uh and then preferably two working 43:34 elevators 43:35 so um what i would ask karen 43:39 um would it help that we have patty 43:41 contact you and go over 43:43 urban development um actually maybe at 43:46 our 43:46 next working session we can talk about 43:49 urban urban development how long we've 43:51 been doing 43:52 urban development and about how we get 43:54 the money as you can see 43:55 what we're reallocating is 2016 17 18 43:59 and 19 44:00 monies that were not used um so i think 44:04 that 44:05 to so that everyone can understand 44:08 we can have a in-depth conversation 44:10 about urban development 44:12 now i just have a general question and i 44:14 don't know if it can be answered patty 44:16 um when the annual citywide 44:21 budget is put together and presented 44:24 would this have been part of that 44:28 did i miss it no uh mike hi 44:32 um as far 44:36 i really got involved in uh community 44:38 development and urban development in 44:40 may when donna asked me to take over the 44:44 program 44:45 so i wasn't involved during the budget 44:47 process 44:48 but it appears to me from the research 44:51 i've done looking back 44:52 at prior years funding and allocations 44:55 that and the resolutions that this was 44:58 done by the city separately 45:00 for example ina's on the phone 45:03 in is on the call i really hate the call 45:06 that that's 45:07 a question i didn't see you there okay 45:09 oh yeah 45:10 i just wanted to say that if i could 45:13 just finish 45:14 that the last time the city took action 45:16 it was in the month of december 45:19 uh two years ago so it wasn't at the 45:21 same time as the budget cycle 45:23 okay thank you paddy 45:26 hi good evening good evening how's 45:29 everyone 45:30 ah yes that is absolutely right so 45:33 revenues and expenses that pertain to 45:36 the urban development grant 45:38 they're not part of the operating funds 45:41 of the city so you don't see this 45:45 information 45:46 when we present a city budget for you to 45:50 vote 45:51 on and uh hence it 45:54 it should go as a separate item um on 45:57 resolution for when the um urban 46:01 development 46:02 grant is budgeted for 46:05 every year it goes on separately so 46:07 basically 46:08 it's a restricted fund god as patty said 46:14 though she described the purpose of the 46:16 ground uh pretty comprehensively 46:19 and um it's maintained separately in 46:22 our erp and what you see now 46:25 in front of you is the funds that were 46:28 received in prior 46:30 years but were not yet spent 46:33 so we are they they had all of those 46:36 years had specific budgets presented to 46:40 the city council 46:41 that were approved by the city council 46:43 so 46:44 now that for those 16 17 18 and 19 46:48 fiscal years 46:49 from those funds that remain in order to 46:52 spend them towards the 46:54 elevator repair you need to approve 46:58 the reallocation of the budget 47:02 and that's what's in front of you 47:07 thank you i hope i 47:10 answered the questions 47:13 yeah i i i'll have a question but i 47:16 haven't thought of it now 47:18 okay sure 47:22 we'll hold a spot for you mike 47:25 uh okay uh any questions from the public 47:29 dave 47:32 uh yes uh kathleen o'leary 47:36 okay okay kathleen go ahead on you 47:44 okay am i on yes you are go ahead okay 47:47 um 47:48 i guess um i have a question on 47:52 i understand the reallocating of the 47:54 prior years to the elevator 47:56 in terms of 2020 um there's 200 000 48:00 in the fund and you know virtual 48:02 services 48:03 for senior center is the only thing 48:06 that's been 48:07 brought up to spend it on i don't think 48:09 virtual 48:11 services are would cost that much what 48:14 about 48:15 putting a handicapped accessible door in 48:17 city law 48:18 and using these 20 20 funds for a door 48:22 that disabled people could get in 48:27 okay uh i'm not sure who the right 48:29 person uh well 48:30 just in case you don't know because 48:31 people haven't been in city hall there 48:33 is a 48:34 handicapped accessible door at city hall 48:37 now on the outside 48:39 wait liz you said something liz but we 48:41 couldn't hear you is it accessible door 48:43 let's let's not use the word handicap 48:46 well i'm sorry an accessible door now at 48:48 city hall 48:51 well i'm still using the main doors and 48:54 um 48:54 i i don't think it's unusual for a 48:57 building to have that kind of a setup 48:59 and i would just like to see it get some 49:01 priority if 49:03 are there other programs this 200 000 is 49:06 is going to go to you 49:10 well just so you know when you come to 49:11 this if you come to city hall just so 49:13 you you use right the door on the right 49:16 side so the door to the right of the 49:18 revolving door 49:19 there's there's a button there a big 49:21 square button you push to open the door 49:24 oh okay i didn't i was there yesterday i 49:27 didn't see it 49:27 okay maybe yeah all right but yeah it's 49:29 it's the door to the right of the 49:30 revolving door 49:31 okay okay and then the grant itself 49:35 and correct me if i'm wrong um patty 49:37 it's for 102 49:39 399. that is correct 49:43 yes right and so that goes towards 49:45 salaries contractor service and 49:46 temporary salaries 49:48 and the senior services that is zoom is 49:51 not just going to go for those services 49:54 it will be for any service programs that 49:56 we we can do not just for 49:58 we're not gonna spend a hundred and two 49:59 thousand dollars on zoom 50:01 for seniors no it supports other 50:04 programs such as 50:06 the street improvements uh bike lanes 50:09 that uh phil ragona talked about 50:13 the non-profit clergy network that we 50:15 started this year 50:16 under covid to expand services 50:20 youth training programs uh tree 50:23 plantings 50:24 it all supports the staffing for all 50:25 those things the 50:27 ada bathrooms on the fifth floor 50:30 for um the mlk youth programs 50:34 and um residential rehab 50:37 uh the college lab at mlk so it's it's 50:40 staff support 50:41 to make these programs work because 50:42 there's a lot of procurement involved 50:45 in any type of uh use of these 50:49 types of funds okay thank you 50:55 okay uh any more questions kathleen or 50:58 did we answer everything 50:59 yes that's everything all right and by 51:01 the way hello we haven't heard from you 51:02 in a while 51:03 i know all right thanks 51:06 um anyone else dave 51:12 you mean uh john john miranda had his 51:14 hand up oh okay 51:15 well john you're muted go ahead just on 51:18 that discussion of the uh 51:20 the accessible door we put that door in 51:23 temporarily but just remember that we 51:25 have a 51:25 uh design going on for a one million 51:28 dollar 51:29 hazard mitigation project being funded 51:31 by fema to re 51:32 do the entire first floor of city hall 51:35 and 51:36 at that time there'll be bigger 51:37 improvements on accessibility 51:40 good good to know 51:44 all right anyone else dave 51:49 hang on one second oh no okay nope 51:52 all right let's move on to item six okay 51:55 and item six is a resolution authorizing 51:57 transfer of funds for the 2020 2021 52:00 fiscal year 52:03 and that's enough 52:08 you muted 52:13 not muted anymore there you go okay 52:17 so um i'm not sure if um you've seen 52:20 this 52:21 a lot in the past but uh um 52:25 the appropriate thing to do is to move 52:29 your budget where operations really 52:32 take you and in this case um 52:36 uh the reason need to increase the 52:39 budget 52:40 in in you know regular salary lines 52:45 um and that's what basically 52:48 this resolution is about uh 52:52 there were as clauses there that explain 52:55 what it's for there were two conversions 52:58 from the part-time positions to the 53:00 full-time positions 53:02 and the majority of 53:05 the difference between those part-time 53:07 salaries and full-time salaries 53:10 are covered by determination in the same 53:13 department however 53:15 um there was a 5400 deficit 53:19 um well but deficit meaning there was a 53:24 shortage 53:24 in a regular salaries line and that was 53:27 brought to 53:29 the department management and brought up 53:32 to the department management 53:34 and they asked to reallocate the funds 53:38 from 53:38 one of their non-personnel lines to this 53:41 line 53:43 so part-time positions can be converted 53:49 okay any questions from the council 53:52 members 53:54 i have one how about it 53:58 um ina yes 54:02 um converting i'm just going to read 54:05 something just 54:06 if i'm understanding this one full-time 54:09 employee 54:10 was terminated and 54:13 two part-time positions 54:17 became full-time positions 54:20 that's accurate yes okay 54:23 i'm assuming then that the terminate 54:25 employee was at a much higher 54:27 salary uh about 40 percent higher 54:32 than whatever this new positions are 54:34 starting at 54:35 okay so you understand my question and 54:38 yeah yeah 54:39 absolutely yeah and 54:42 the other part is 54:45 the benefit packages that go along with 54:48 these 54:49 are called benefit package the benefits 54:51 attached to each employee 54:53 would appear in a different line item in 54:55 the budget 54:56 yes okay thank you that's right sure 55:01 okay anyone else karen you look like you 55:04 got one 55:05 yeah of course um hyena 55:09 first off i want to um commend um 55:12 i think it is um mr scott is that 55:15 correct donna 55:17 for this uh for this recommendation and 55:20 you 55:22 you muted donna 55:26 yes i'm having problems like everybody 55:28 else being muted 55:31 i thought um i thought this was showed 55:33 real uh leadership 55:34 and innovation and then a real concern 55:38 for 55:38 our for our employees to bring two 55:41 part-time employees to full-time 55:43 and um that benefits with benefits um i 55:48 congratulate 55:49 these uh new full-time employees 55:52 personally 55:52 very happy for them and very proud that 55:55 um 55:56 i work with colleagues that are are 55:59 really concerned about their employees 56:01 and want 56:01 and want to see the best for them so 56:03 thank you very very much 56:05 thank you and i'll make sure that um 56:08 greg and his staff 56:10 hears about your thank yous yes mr scott 56:13 way to go 56:14 okay so then so then i have to look at 56:16 the number side 56:17 so i thought about um i looked at the 56:19 past two personnel reports 56:21 and i sort of figured out that yes the 56:23 higher the uh the full-time employee 56:25 that left was making a large salary 56:27 and that the two part-timers that are 56:29 moving to full-time 56:30 are making a smaller salary a lower 56:33 salary 56:33 lower salaries even including benefits 56:37 i understand why the increase uh the 56:40 transfer has to happen 56:41 however i think i'm missing 56:44 um a quantif a quantification 56:47 of the amount that we are going to save 56:50 in part-time 56:51 um expenses um 56:55 i'm unmuted right yes 56:58 okay sure so um in a part-time expenses 57:02 we are saving um 57:06 about um 57:09 39 about 40 000 57:12 on an annual basis this two employees 57:15 who 57:15 uh whose position have been converted 57:18 that's what they were making on an 57:20 annual basis 57:22 exactly so so basically 57:25 to me this this analysis is incomplete 57:27 because it doesn't include the fact that 57:29 we're saving forty thousand dollars 57:31 and that that's on my checklist of how 57:33 much we're saving you know that our and 57:35 honest checklist that we're saving money 57:37 even while we're helping bring part-time 57:39 employees to full-time employment status 57:42 including with benefits so i think that 57:45 you know 57:45 again i commend you for doing this but i 57:48 think it 57:49 we missed the point that we're also 57:51 saving money actually 57:54 um we're saving money in one of the 57:58 lines 57:58 in one of the salary lines however there 58:01 will be an 58:01 increase the net increase of this 58:04 transition 58:05 is fifty four hundred dollars um 58:08 i find that hard to believe i really do 58:12 okay um okay so i'll take a look at it 58:15 one of the reasons that we said that we 58:17 we have not mentioned 58:18 savings is because we're looking at 58:21 how many employees that are part-time 58:24 and once we get money 58:25 how many more we can bring on full-time 58:28 so 58:29 so we won't when we say we only needed 58:31 the 5400 that was to convert the other 58:34 two 58:35 if something happens then we can say 58:37 based on the savings from the part-time 58:39 line 58:40 and based on savings from somebody else 58:42 leaving now we can convert 58:44 one other additional person so i 58:46 understand what you're saying karen but 58:48 that's why we didn't put it out there 58:50 because we are still trying to figure 58:52 out if we can do any more conversions 58:54 this year 58:55 so it's two peak to be continued which 58:57 is again 58:58 to be continued yes and then um my only 59:02 my only other my final statement on this 59:04 on this analysis 59:05 is that i just want to put it on the 59:07 record that i am 59:10 i really would like to see departmental 59:12 costs which include payroll taxes and 59:15 benefits within one department instead 59:17 of a lump sum 59:18 for all csa members all fire department 59:21 and all police department 59:22 because it really makes analyzing these 59:24 types of costs difficult 59:27 for someone thank you 59:32 okay anyone else 59:37 all right here none do we have any 59:39 questions from the public 59:41 yes we do roy lester okay you're unmuted 59:44 go ahead 59:46 okay um i i have to say i agree with 59:48 karen that it would be great if we could 59:50 see the benefits within the department 59:52 but i i don't see how we're saving money 59:55 on this 59:56 i think what we're doing is we're 59:58 gaining two workers which is 60:00 absolutely great now my question is we 60:02 have 60:03 almost a quarter million set aside for 60:05 overtime is this going to affect the 60:07 overtime at all 60:09 can we come down on that 60:13 roy we're looking at everything as a 60:15 whole um and so what i will say is that 60:17 as we do our analysis we will start 60:19 looking at overtime 60:21 um and looking at past right now we're 60:24 working on the conversions 60:26 so i i want you to to know that we're 60:29 looking at everything as a whole 60:31 um and we probably can answer within the 60:34 next month about the overtime because we 60:36 had to get control 60:37 of the overtime okay i i think the 60:40 conversions are a great idea 60:42 and you know it's i i really like the 60:44 idea that these guys who had these 60:46 temporary positions of part-time 60:47 positions now have the full-time 60:49 positions 60:50 because they always seem to be treated 60:52 as kind of second-class citizens in 60:54 those part-time positions 60:56 and you know they they're great guys 60:59 those guys i do have a question though 61:02 the 61:03 money that it came from came from 61:06 supplies and material 61:08 now last year when we did the budget we 61:11 we normally spend around twenty thousand 61:13 twenty five thousand on supplies and 61:15 materials 61:16 but last year the budget was raised to 61:18 fifty five thousand more than doubled on 61:20 supplies and materials 61:22 and now we're finding that supplies and 61:24 materials we have extra money 61:27 how are we so wrong 61:30 well we can't tell you about the prior 61:32 year's budget because 61:33 nor ena nor i was here when the prior 61:36 year budget 61:37 was done however this year's budget 61:39 everyone was told that they have 61:41 they are accountable for their budget 61:43 and because we were reducing 61:45 everyone's budget i i believe that they 61:48 came in looking at things more 61:51 realistically 61:52 and as well as that the information they 61:54 received wasn't just for prior year 61:56 it was also for at least three years 61:59 prior to that 62:00 um so i think now people and along with 62:03 the finance people we're all looking at 62:05 what we're really spending and not what 62:07 we 62:08 we're looking at our needs not 62:09 necessarily our wants on certain line 62:11 items 62:12 well but that's that's what i mean it 62:14 went from 25 000 62:15 in 2020 to 55 000 in 2021 so what we're 62:20 doing is that there's something there 62:22 we'll have to go back and look to see 62:24 what they're asking for that needed to 62:26 go on that line 62:28 and and now we say we well we have 5400 62:31 extra 62:32 in that line so they may have had a 62:35 savings 62:36 every line item that every department 62:38 does they have to tell 62:39 us what they're looking for to purchase 62:42 within that line item 62:43 if they can come in under what they 62:45 budgeted for then there's a savings 62:48 yeah and and right just remember one 62:50 thing one of the hallmarks of budgets in 62:52 previous years was 62:53 underestimating of expenses so 62:57 the budget this year was trying to be 62:59 more in line with the reality of what 63:02 they've been spending historically so 63:05 that that may also be i'm not saying 63:07 that's specific to this line item in the 63:09 budget but that may be what the 63:11 what are the uh the factors that may 63:13 have caused it to change 63:15 but john you can see each year what they 63:17 spend and they never spend 55 000 63:20 never even close but all right okay 63:22 regardless i 63:23 think that that's true they may not have 63:26 but they may have seen that there was 63:27 something 63:28 in this current year which we will get 63:30 back to you on 63:32 that they needed to spend extra money on 63:35 they have to justify why they came up 63:37 with that number 63:38 we didn't just put that number in there 63:40 because we thought it was a good number 63:44 so they justified that they were 63:45 purchasing something that would increase 63:47 it 63:47 and we can get that information to you 63:49 yeah 63:50 that that's consistent to any light item 63:53 if you had twenty thousand twenty five 63:54 thousand a year before thirty 63:56 twenty and you go to 60 somewhere along 63:59 the line 64:00 it's going to be explained the need now 64:02 if that need doesn't exist anymore 64:04 yes it goes back and but i um 64:07 i want to thank you roy for really going 64:09 through 64:10 all of these line items and asking these 64:13 questions 64:14 and uh you know it would have been nice 64:19 had we all been as diligent three years 64:21 ago but 64:23 i i'm here now and uh i think 64:27 that's what everybody is focusing in on 64:30 every person that you see 64:31 in this video does 64:35 look at those numbers and donna 64:38 looks at them daily so i'm more 64:41 comfortable 64:42 i hope you are but i hope you um you 64:45 know 64:46 keep looking at these things and you 64:47 know pointing them out this year 64:50 at least michael this year i'm getting 64:52 answers to mine we always 64:54 looked at the numbers we just didn't get 64:56 answers oh 64:57 i i am i stand corrected thank you 65:03 all right um john mirando commissioner 65:05 rando just 65:06 asked me a question commissioner that 65:08 could be what the extra money was for 65:10 you can mention it 65:11 um i'm not sure but that could be what 65:14 it was for 65:16 but you're on mute so you can mention it 65:22 there's commissioner out there yeah he's 65:24 still on commissioner 65:26 he's unmuted now yeah i believe the 65:29 additional money in materials and 65:30 supplies and sanitation was to 65:32 uh purchase about 25 to 30 000 65:36 worth of um garbage pails for the west 65:39 end to replace some of the street cans 65:42 and then i believe uh that that's going 65:45 to be part of a capital assistance grant 65:47 that we got from senator kaminsky 65:49 so that's that may be part of the 65:51 reasons we're not going to spend that 65:52 whole 15. 65:54 and i think that's what it was but i you 65:56 know i 65:57 we will check to verify but thanks 65:59 commissioner i um i think that was it 66:04 okay get it right yep thank you 66:07 okay thank you anyone else dave 66:10 yes we do one second uh kathleen o'leary 66:15 oh welcome back 66:18 um hi i'd like to speak about the um 66:21 conversion of the bus a garage 66:24 potentially to a popeyes 66:26 oh that's that's not that that'll be 66:28 next when we do good in welfare 66:30 oh i'm sorry i thought we were doing 66:31 good no no not yet we're getting close 66:37 okay uh anyone else dave 66:42 nope that's it okay let's move on to 66:44 item seven 66:45 okay item seven is a resolution to 66:47 schedule a special meeting of the city 66:48 council on thursday october 29th 2020. 66:53 okay and uh that's the the purpose of 66:57 the meeting 66:57 is that the special meeting we will be 67:00 reviewing 67:01 and approving uh policies 67:05 a whole lot of them um 67:11 all right uh any questions from the 67:13 council 67:14 i i just have one question and uh 67:17 and donna i don't know if you can answer 67:19 this or not 67:20 but it has to do with the october 29th 67:24 the policies 67:25 there is a lot of data there and i think 67:29 that's why 67:30 we are scheduling a special meeting and 67:33 yes 67:34 for example if mr lester wants to read 67:37 all of these policies 67:38 in advance i would gather that he would 67:44 just be given a heads up that this is 67:46 going to be rather lengthy read 67:49 would i be it is yes it is a very 67:52 lengthy read um 67:54 we have been working on these policies 67:56 with cma for quite a while 67:58 um and they've gone through legal review 68:01 they've gone through 68:02 all types of reviews so that they are 68:05 policies for 68:06 government um for a municipality so 68:09 roy if you want to take a look at the 68:12 policies i will gladly give you 68:14 we can send you a copy um because i know 68:18 you 68:18 but it's a lengthy reading we can get 68:21 those 68:22 if possible i will talk to dave frazier 68:25 people that want to 68:26 ask questions about um 68:29 any of the policies um we'll have the 68:32 list out shortly 68:34 of all of the policies so i'm also 68:36 reminding the council that if you have 68:37 any 68:38 questions please get those to me because 68:40 i'm not the only one that answers the 68:41 questions 68:42 and so i want to make sure we get all 68:44 the questions and everything sent back 68:46 in a timely manner for the meeting 68:49 i know it's a lot of reading yeah and 68:52 the reason i pointed out because i i 68:54 know roy seems to like to 68:57 review everything right i personally 68:59 like people 69:01 i'd like to give him an opportunity 69:03 because i know 69:04 getting it on let's say if it's a 69:06 thursday meeting or whatever day of the 69:08 week it is 69:08 i'm getting it two or three days before 69:10 is going to 69:12 be a lengthy overnight read and that's 69:15 all i'm asking for if there's 69:16 any way um that could happen thank you 69:20 okay all right any other 69:23 questions 69:27 all right dave anything no hands raised 69:29 at this time 69:31 okay then let's get on to the voting 69:34 okay we'll start with item number two 69:35 which is a resolution authorizing the 69:37 city manager to amend 69:38 the agreement for architectural 69:40 engineering design services for the city 69:41 of long beach bulkheading north shore 69:43 project and to amend the budget 69:45 we'll introduce a move the adoption of 69:46 this item i will 69:49 second i will 69:52 voting councilmember delivery yes 69:55 councilmember mandel 69:56 yes councilmember tristan yes 69:59 vice president mcginnis yes president 70:02 bendo 70:03 yes item three is a resolution 70:05 authorizing the city manager to enter to 70:07 a contract for street lighting 70:08 maintenance and repair with the lowest 70:10 responsible bidder 70:11 would you just move the adoption of this 70:13 item 70:15 i will second 70:20 i will pick one okay 70:23 owen councilmember delorey yes 70:26 councilmember mandel 70:27 yes councilmember treston yes vice 70:31 president mcginnis 70:32 yes president pendo yes item four is the 70:36 resolution authorizing the city manager 70:37 to accept funds 70:38 from the new york state municipal 70:40 workers compensation alliance who want 70:42 to just move the adoption of this item i 70:44 will 70:45 second i will 70:50 voting councilman delorey 70:53 i didn't is god okay uh yes but i 70:56 don't know if i heard something some 70:58 noise uh councilmember mandel 71:01 yes okay uh 71:04 councilmember treston yes vice president 71:07 mcginnis 71:08 yes president bendo yes 71:11 item five is the resolution authorizing 71:13 amendments to the urban development fund 71:15 budget years 2016 71:16 17 18 19 and 20. i wouldn't just remove 71:19 the adoption of this item 71:23 i will second i will 71:27 voting councilman delorey yes 71:30 councilmember mandel 71:32 yes councilmember tresten 71:35 vice president mcginnis i want to say 71:38 that 71:39 on this item i agree we need to fix the 71:42 elevator that's not in question 71:44 but i think it's a poor use of urban 71:46 development funds to 71:48 fix the elevator so therefore i vote no 71:51 president pendo yes okay item 71:55 six is a resolution authorizing transfer 71:57 of funds for the 2020-2021 fiscal year 72:00 won't you just move the adoption of this 72:01 item 72:04 i will second i will 72:09 voting councilmember delorey yes 72:11 councilmember mandel 72:13 yes councilmember treston yes vice 72:16 president mcginnis 72:17 yes president bendo yes 72:20 and finally item seven is a resolution 72:22 to schedule a special meeting of the 72:23 city council on 72:24 thursday october 29th 2020. which just 72:27 remove the adoption of this item 72:31 i will second 72:35 i will vote in council member delorey 72:39 yes councilmember mandel yes 72:42 councilmember trusted yes vice president 72:45 mcginnis 72:46 yes president bendo 72:49 city manager's personnel report has been 72:51 filed by the city clerk we'll make a 72:52 motion to close the meeting 72:55 i will second 72:58 i will 73:03 morning councilman delorey 73:06 yes councilmember mandel yes 73:09 councilmember treston yes vice president 73:12 mcginnis 73:13 yes and president pendo yes 73:17 okay and 73:21 oh one thing we should also note um is 73:24 that the next 73:25 regular meeting is not gonna it's going 73:27 to be on a wednesday because of election 73:29 day 73:30 so just everybody keep that in mind that 73:32 we will have the special meeting 73:34 but we also have the regular meeting 73:36 will be on the 73:37 on november 4th 73:41 just wanted to mention that thank you 73:43 okay okay 73:46 all right and all right so on to 73:50 good and welfare um so i think most 73:53 people know the drill but just in case 73:55 you're a first timer 73:56 what you got something dave no no oh 73:59 okay 74:00 uh so you get three papers you get three 74:02 minutes 74:03 um please uh 74:06 act with some decorum and um 74:10 okay who's up first yeah folks just a 74:12 reminder you can use the raise your hand 74:14 function if you want to speak at 74:15 good and welfare uh we have three 74:17 speakers so far we're going to start 74:18 with roy lester 74:20 okay go ahead wow 74:24 okay um on the parking that you did the 74:27 other day 74:28 at the work session i have a couple of 74:29 questions in our revenue we have 74:32 commuter parking lot 74:33 fees is that just i'm not sure what 74:37 what money that is from 74:40 and we also have parking meter fees and 74:42 i'm not sure what that money is for 74:44 from can you answer that and not take my 74:47 time 74:49 maybe i will try okay 74:54 okay so um the commuter 74:58 parking account is for 75:01 the parking at the long island railroad 75:04 train station 75:05 and the other one roy what did you say 75:08 what was the other one 75:12 yeah that's the parking meter so um 75:16 we actually combine um 75:20 uh revenues received for this 75:25 municipal parking lot it's uh 75:28 included if you have the city budget in 75:31 front of you 75:32 it's included in the clerk 75:36 um fees line clerk fees 75:39 yes okay so what are the parking meter 75:43 fees 75:46 you know are those are those those the 75:49 muni meters at the train station yes 75:52 yeah because we have muni meters that so 75:54 people who don't buy an 75:55 annual pass for the long island railroad 75:58 uh 75:58 parking lot there are muni meters for 76:01 people who park by the day 76:05 so why did why did the projection for 76:09 uh i guess it might have been coveted or 76:11 something that went down from 125 000 76:14 down to 90 76:15 000 this year was it because of kobig 76:19 the majority of the declines were due to 76:21 corvid yes 76:23 yeah productive declines yes 76:26 and our biggest revenue for the parking 76:30 are the fines we make four hundred 76:34 thousand dollars in parking violation 76:36 fines 76:38 uh we do however not 76:41 all of it is at those parking lots that 76:44 we were discussing 76:49 i'm saying if we do have meters and 76:52 stuff like that 76:53 won't that money go down 76:58 well a lot of that the parking fines a 77:01 lot of that people who park illegally 77:04 down by the beach and in those the 77:05 center medians and 77:08 and things like that i don't think it's 77:09 just in the uh 77:11 the few pay lots 77:14 no i but in the center medium i guess we 77:17 wouldn't be giving them i guess we'd 77:19 still get something on 77:20 on these the parking meters uh one other 77:23 question before my time 77:24 the other day we moved some people from 77:27 beach maintenance 77:29 over to the sewer department not some 77:31 people but 77:32 uh the fees uh what we were paying it 77:35 was like twelve thousand dollars 77:37 um and yet in beach maintenance 77:41 we have one of the biggest overtime 77:43 budgets in the city that's uh 77:46 400 000 in overtime 77:49 by moving people out of beach 77:51 maintenance because they're not 77:53 needed and that was the the explanation 77:56 that was given they were needed in the 77:58 sewer department they're not needed in 77:59 the beige maintenance 78:01 i don't understand then how do we run up 78:03 400 000 78:04 worth of overtime and then get rid of 78:06 people 78:08 because they're not needed 78:11 okay um that's a that's a question that 78:14 uh roy 78:15 um i will have the department heads give 78:17 you a call 78:18 um why we felt the need to move people 78:22 and so that they can better explain the 78:25 overtime to you okay i i know you told 78:29 me you needed the people in the sewer 78:31 department which listen i'm not arguing 78:33 about 78:34 it's just i guess when i see a 400 000 78:37 overtime bill and then we're saying well 78:39 we don't need the people 78:41 i guess it just kind of bothers me all 78:44 right well 78:44 part of the overtime watch i will tell 78:46 you part of the overtime is that 78:48 we have projects that we do in-house 78:50 versus sending them 78:52 out and so even though we are spending a 78:55 lot of money and over time we do have a 78:57 savings 78:58 because we're using the staff that we 79:00 have but i will have the 79:02 the two people give you a call and then 79:04 um 79:05 we'll talk about that okay thank you 79:08 all right thanks for one i'm sorry last 79:11 thing 79:12 um on the parking i mean the bike lanes 79:14 on broadway 79:16 it's really nice they're being repainted 79:18 but if you allow people to park 79:21 and you allow them to put their garbage 79:23 out front and stuff like that i mean the 79:25 allegory is one of the worst offenders 79:27 you can never go by there without that 79:30 that bike lane being blocked 79:32 and all up and down broadway the bike 79:34 lane is blocked 79:35 at different places if there's no 79:37 enforcement then you're kind of wasting 79:39 your time making a bike lane there 79:42 because then it just puts the people out 79:44 into the street which is dangerous 79:47 so i'm asking for a little bit of 79:49 enforcement when it comes to that 79:51 and i know the allegory is a tough one 79:52 to enforce things on 79:54 but why have a bike lane if people are 79:57 going to park in it 79:59 will do all right thank you 80:05 all right who's next dave next is 80:07 kathleen o'leary 80:09 go kathleen okay okay now i'd like to 80:13 speak about the 80:14 bus garage okay um there's a few things 80:17 i know the city council is considering 80:20 uh the offer uh to put a popeyes in 80:23 there 80:24 but there's a couple of things i would 80:25 like to have considered 80:27 um first of all this is the main 80:28 entrance to long beach 80:30 and what you have when you come over the 80:34 bridge 80:34 is you have a huge mcdonald's there 80:37 with a big american flag which is fine 80:40 um 80:41 then you have the bus garage and then on 80:42 the other side you have taco bell 80:45 and kentucky fried chicken so the idea 80:48 of 80:48 putting another fast food restaurant in 80:51 the middle 80:52 just doesn't seem like the image that we 80:55 want to project 80:57 i know years ago when they were thinking 80:59 of putting the dunkin donuts in the west 81:01 end 81:03 everyone was saying not too big we don't 81:05 want box stores here and so forth 81:07 and this just seems like it would be 81:09 fast food 81:10 alley um i did a real little research 81:14 on the bus garage and it turns out that 81:17 the city 81:17 bought it from a t in 1939 81:21 and it's quite possible it was built in 81:24 the 20s 81:25 so you're speaking of a building that 81:29 blends in with the architecture of many 81:32 of the 81:33 uh landmark buildings in long beach i've 81:35 always noticed the clay 81:37 roof piece and the shape of the windows 81:40 so um and also i i've tutored in the 81:44 houses 81:44 in back of these um establishments 81:48 i don't think the people there's a lot 81:50 of noise back there just from 81:52 long beach road i don't think the 81:54 residents are going to be happy 81:56 with you know people lining up for a 81:58 takeout window 82:00 right on top of their houses so i would 82:03 like those factors to be considered 82:06 um i i do like popeyes i don't think 82:09 it's i think it's a good 82:10 as fast food goes i think it's very good 82:13 but um there's 82:14 plenty of open space in lido 82:18 and atlanta beach if they want to put a 82:20 popeyes there for this island 82:22 um and i would rather see the bus garage 82:26 stay and the other thing is if it's 82:29 possible 82:30 i would like to see a cost-benefit 82:32 analysis 82:33 of how much it's going to you know and 82:36 in other words we're going to have to 82:38 get another building for the bus garage 82:40 um 82:41 i think it's said that the environmental 82:43 study has to be done before 82:45 the proposal my question is who pays for 82:48 that do we pay for that 82:49 or does the buyer pay for it and i'm 82:52 questioning whether or not 82:54 it's cost benefit effective to make this 82:56 switch over 82:58 thank you 83:01 okay um so 83:05 just so you know uh commissioner morando 83:08 addressed this 83:09 earlier the any 83:12 if the city decides to consider selling 83:15 the property 83:16 the buyer would have to do an 83:17 environmental assessment on the 83:20 property if they want to purchase it 83:22 okay the city will do it 83:24 is going to do an environmental 83:26 assessment on 83:28 the site where they the garage would 83:31 likely go should the city sell that 83:34 property 83:34 so that's that's uh what the city is 83:38 doing 83:39 um but there have been several 83:42 expressions of interest in that property 83:44 one 83:44 one thing that you should be aware of is 83:47 that that property 83:48 is no longer adequate for the city's 83:52 needs it's not 83:53 large enough for what they need it isn't 83:55 properly equipped 83:57 um and also it 84:00 it floods uh a fair amount 84:04 uh in very heavy rains so 84:08 um even if they were to keep the 84:11 building there my understanding is and 84:13 john mirando can jump in if i'm wrong 84:15 but my understanding is there would have 84:17 to be 84:17 a very significant investment made in 84:20 the building just to 84:23 keep it habitable usable for what the 84:25 city needs it to do 84:27 and it might actually be more cost 84:28 effective to actually do a new building 84:31 because we can get grant money to pay 84:33 for a 84:34 a nice chunk of it 84:37 okay so but all that it would be 84:40 factored into all of this you know we 84:41 can't 84:42 uh obviously we can't just sell the 84:45 property if we don't have some place to 84:47 move the city's 84:49 you know uh maintenance operas uh 84:51 vehicle maintenance operations to 84:53 um because we still have a lot of 84:56 vehicles that have to be maintained 84:58 um and we're not going to we're not 85:01 going to do it in 85:02 councilman delorey's driveway so 85:07 so that's all going to be you know part 85:09 of the consideration 85:11 okay thank you john okay thank you john 85:15 all right uh we can't do it in your 85:18 driveway you don't even have one 85:21 so uh all right dave who's next 85:24 uh next is eileen hession okay good 85:28 evening everyone 85:29 hi ellie um i listened to the work 85:32 session the other night which was very 85:34 interesting i appreciate 85:35 you having the transparency and letting 85:38 us listen 85:38 in one of the topics was about the 85:41 martin luther king center 85:43 which has been closed and i know it's 85:46 important to restore 85:47 the programs that go on there but i have 85:50 a couple of questions i'll ask a bunch 85:52 of them in a row 85:54 who owns the center who is the director 85:59 who should be doing those safety plans 86:02 in order to open the center 86:04 why isn't that person being held 86:06 accountable to write up 86:08 the uh safety plans at this point is the 86:12 building 86:12 insured 86:19 sorry i think we lost i'm sorry about 86:21 that 86:22 sorry about that 86:27 do you have me now yeah sorry about that 86:28 get back okay where was i 86:31 the building insured yes and then 86:34 um how can voting take place there if 86:38 it's not insured and if it needs to be 86:40 kept closed so that's it 86:43 about them 86:47 peace among okay 86:50 you're muted simone simone you're muted 86:56 sorry i said can you please just repeat 87:00 the questions again i apologize i was 87:01 writing and trying to write quickly 87:04 who owns the building who's the director 87:06 who should be doing the safety plans why 87:09 isn't he being held accountable if it's 87:11 his fault that the building is closed 87:13 is the building insured how can we have 87:16 voting take place there if it's closed 87:19 okay so we own the building it is our 87:22 building 87:23 city property um 87:26 there is not a city director 87:29 currently in the facility we we did over 87:32 the years on and off have people in and 87:34 out of there 87:34 from the department of parks and 87:35 recreation and have done 87:37 programming up until covet or some 87:40 programming shared with them 87:42 um it is being currently 87:46 um occupied i guess you could say uh by 87:50 the 87:50 mlk center inc which is a not for profit 87:55 um they are responsible 87:59 for providing a schedule of programming 88:02 to us 88:03 and a schedule of programming 88:06 based upon you know what they're going 88:08 to be doing in the building and based 88:09 upon 88:11 um you know the types of activities that 88:13 are able to be reopened right now 88:16 so with that each 88:19 site safety plan the mlk center inc 88:21 would be responsible for their site 88:23 safety plan and it would have to be 88:24 specific 88:25 to the types of activities that they are 88:29 proposing so that's why we need a 88:30 programming schedule 88:32 and then the program schedule dictates 88:34 the site safety plan 88:36 they have as i mentioned during our 88:38 during the last work session they've 88:40 advised us that they will not be in a 88:41 position 88:42 to move forward until november 10th um 88:47 they we have been following up regularly 88:50 they have just obtained legal counsel 88:52 and legal counsel has just reached out 88:54 to us 88:55 the site safety plans are quite arduous 88:58 which is why we had reached out to them 89:00 in 89:00 july to try to help them along um but it 89:04 is their responsibility and their 89:05 responsibility to provide a schedule of 89:07 programming to us 89:08 in order for them to reopen um to be 89:11 open 89:11 you know just generally i don't know if 89:13 you've watched any of the previous work 89:15 sessions but 89:16 you know recreation was only permitted 89:19 to open 89:20 in phase four and that was mid to late 89:23 august 89:24 and then school type activities and 89:27 educational 89:28 was not permitted until the beginning of 89:30 september 89:31 so that's where we are in that now the 89:34 building is insured we insure the 89:35 building 89:36 um they also the mlk center inc 89:39 also does provide us with insurance uh 89:42 for the 89:43 activities that they do perform in the 89:45 building 89:46 uh the when they're approved um 89:51 insured oh and voting yes voting can 89:53 absolutely take place there because as i 89:54 said it's a 89:55 city-owned building it's a city facility 89:59 and we insure the building so it would 90:02 be covered under our insurance 90:04 and do they pay us rent they do not they 90:07 have not been paying us rent 90:10 so why don't we sell it to somebody else 90:13 well we don't they don't own it we own 90:15 it we 90:17 i know why don't we sell it to somebody 90:18 who will pay rent how long have they 90:20 stopped paying rent 90:22 well we wouldn't sell it to someone i 90:25 mean we 90:26 could rent it to someone however it's 90:29 been 90:29 i think we've discussed this on previous 90:31 calls it has been 90:34 i believe in estimated about 10 years or 90:36 so 90:37 since they have been paying rent since 90:40 they haven't been paying rent well 90:41 that's ridiculous 90:43 that's a good place to get some money 90:46 all right um that seems to be a real 90:48 mess 90:51 i have one other question not about 90:52 martin luther king 90:55 the erosion on the beach is amazing if 90:58 you've gone down and looked at it and i 91:00 know the 91:01 jetties are partly to blame is the army 91:03 corps coming back 91:07 i see john is on commissioner mirando 91:10 you want to answer that question 91:17 you muted john yeah no i just got muted 91:20 um 91:20 actually the army corps was there today 91:22 to do an inspection of the crossovers 91:24 and the uh 91:24 dune um uh 91:28 the dune plantings uh we did have our 91:31 consultant from 91:32 coastal protection engineering in 91:33 florida come out on friday which was 91:35 supposed to be the original date of the 91:36 army corps inspection 91:39 um and we did review 91:42 all the uh the groins and review some of 91:45 the areas that are eroding the biggest 91:47 erosion problems 91:49 that we're having are at locations where 91:51 the groins were not replaced 91:53 by the army corps um there is a certain 91:56 amount of natural 91:58 erosion that's going that is taking 92:00 place now we've had some storms 92:02 uh we are in the process of developing 92:05 uh 92:06 and approving a draft operation and 92:08 maintenance plan uh we will be 92:11 once that plan is adopted we will be 92:13 able to move some sand around 92:14 which will lessen some of the impacts of 92:16 uh of the beach erosion 92:18 but according to the army corps design 92:21 people uh 92:22 what's happened what's taking place is 92:24 just the reshaping of the slope 92:26 uh and over the winter there will seem 92:28 to be a lot more erosion 92:29 but as the summer comes again the sand 92:32 will place itself back in some of the 92:34 areas that it's missing 92:35 we're still always going to have a 92:36 problem with the groins that weren't 92:38 replaced because it's uh 92:40 as opposed to being you know 800 or a 92:42 thousand feet between groins 92:43 those locations are about 2 000 feet 92:46 apart 92:47 so that's why those look ridiculous that 92:49 the ones that weren't done it's like 92:50 yeah and you know what i'm talking about 92:53 john with it's almost three feet 92:55 it's like a big slope they they call 92:58 those uh scops 92:59 yeah we're getting scarp development and 93:01 then our beach maintenance people will 93:02 knock them down we left some of the 93:04 scoffs there over the last couple of 93:05 weeks because we knew they were coming 93:07 out to inspect and we wanted them to see 93:08 them 93:09 oh good uh we also just gave away a lot 93:11 of sand 93:12 to somebody the town of hempstead or 93:14 something can we get it back 93:15 no that's sand just so you know that was 93:17 not saying 93:18 uh we had an issue with the town of 93:21 hampstead to help us 93:23 when the army corps left the maintenance 93:25 aisle between the 93:27 uh the land side of the dune and the 93:29 boardwalk 93:30 was supposed to be left at an elevation 93:32 of seven feet 93:33 so that we could get maintenance 93:35 equipment under the crossovers to 93:37 maintain that 93:38 that maintenance aisle because if you 93:40 don't maintain the maintenance aisle 93:41 what happens eventually it fills up with 93:42 sand and eventually will take over the 93:44 boardwalk 93:44 right so uh what when they left 93:48 uh they had left the elevation annoying 93:51 so we needed to remove sand 93:53 we did not have the large equipment to 93:55 take the sand over the dune and into 93:57 trucks 93:58 so we we agreed to work with the town of 94:00 hempstead 94:01 and we took that sand out and gave that 94:03 to them and that was 94:04 how we paid for using the trucks so 94:07 that's right that's worked 94:08 out to our advantage thank you and can 94:10 that sandal likely come back to us in a 94:12 year or two right commissioner 94:14 yeah this this yes absolutely you know 94:16 the sand moves from uh 94:19 from east to the west and uh there's 94:22 the town doesn't have as many coins as 94:24 we do uh even so 94:26 we'll be getting a lot of that sand back 94:27 over the next year very good 94:29 um my final comment i guess which is 94:32 beating a dead horse 94:33 is that south nassau is starting to 94:35 build in the hospital area there 94:37 next week and i think some pressure 94:40 should be put on south nassau to knock 94:42 down the old long beach hospital because 94:44 it is 94:45 it's a nightmare that's all thank you 94:48 very much 94:49 good night good night 94:52 all right anyone else dave yes 94:55 uh next we have judy vining okay 94:58 hi judy 95:05 i am i muted unmuted no you're unmuted 95:08 good 95:09 okay hi um i think my three minutes and 95:12 this in 95:14 insane world that we're living in and 95:15 i'm probably going to be schizophrenic 95:17 i'm going to talk to his 95:18 director of long beach aware but then as 95:21 somebody who lives here which is a 95:24 intermingled but separate issue um 95:28 in this crazy virtual world we're living 95:31 in i get to attend a 95:33 an inordinate amount of uh zoom webinars 95:37 and 95:37 it's facts and it's figures and it's 95:39 about 95:40 trends that the state is seeing both 95:44 in nassau county and across the state 95:47 and 95:48 our job i believe is to be a resource to 95:51 you 95:52 you guys cannot possibly know all the 95:56 details 95:57 we get i wish i didn't know all the 95:59 details we get but 96:00 the point is um as an example 96:05 we have what two or three uh cbd stores 96:08 in long beach it's not that cbd is 96:11 illegal 96:12 it is not but there is no one place 96:16 uh no place in the united states that 96:18 you can 96:20 sell edible cbd products or produce 96:24 a shake or anything like that and put 96:26 cbd in it 96:28 um you could not possibly be expected to 96:31 know that 96:32 i i wouldn't know you know what to do 96:34 about a beach groin 96:36 not my area of expertise but this this 96:38 is ours and we can 96:39 offer it to you so it prevents something 96:43 from becoming a um an enforcement issue 96:47 when it could have been a preventative 96:50 issue 96:52 you know if you're following my drift 96:53 about that i mean 96:55 i know a lot more about you know 96:58 we again are geared towards underage 97:02 not only drinking but other drugs which 97:04 brings me to 97:06 a change that we need in the code of 97:08 ordinances and i think mr mandel was 97:10 involved the last time we changed our 97:12 social host 97:13 law but somehow 97:16 somehow we did not include marijuana 97:21 given the fact that at some point 97:25 it's probably likely that non-um 97:29 medical use of marijuana may in fact 97:33 be approved in the state of new york we 97:34 need to get that into 97:36 our code of ordinances and we need you 97:39 guys i mean i know 97:41 liz has been at our meetings i'm sure 97:42 she shared it with you but just 97:44 you know a lot goes on and so i wanted 97:48 to talk to you about how we need to do 97:50 that 97:51 um other things have worked much better 97:54 virtually 97:56 our coalition meetings people who 97:59 you know would have stayed in long beach 98:02 but the building principle of something 98:04 or somebody else we have like 28 29 98:07 people so that's 98:08 actually working better and it's not 98:10 costing us for 98:12 the pizza um 98:16 and the program we have going on with 98:18 the courts 98:20 and the under uh open container law with 98:23 kids has turned out to be um 98:27 so much better virtually we always have 98:30 the kids 98:30 come into the building that we're not 98:33 using now because we're working remotely 98:36 and you know my staff would go through 98:38 it and i would have more discussion but 98:40 going online forced us to make it very 98:42 concrete 98:43 to be able to do pre and post surveys 98:46 and then the courts 98:48 because they want to limit contact as 98:50 well are asking 98:52 anyone who completes it to put in a 98:55 page or two statement that's that's your 98:58 three minutes judy 98:59 oh okay well then i don't get to the 99:01 person schizophrenic but 99:04 can i just say that could we look at 99:07 a mask mandate because if you go to a 99:09 lot of other 99:11 communities out east fire island 99:13 everybody's wearing masks 99:16 outside because the latest data 99:19 is that it's airborne and it can travel 99:22 up to 12 feet and if you go on that 99:24 boardwalk 99:25 and we would like people to right 99:26 because we really want them not having 99:29 gatherings in their house um almost 99:31 nobody's wearing one and you are not 99:34 12 feet away from people just the 99:37 thought 99:37 okay uh judy i'll i'll give you a call 99:40 tomorrow you could 99:41 whatever the other thing you wanted to 99:43 talk about you could just uh i'll get it 99:44 from you tomorrow 99:45 okay all right sure 99:49 all right um but thanks 99:52 all right dave anyone else our last 99:54 speaker is uh leah tozer 99:57 ms tozer 100:01 hi hello how's it going 100:06 long time no speak i know i just want to 100:09 say 100:10 like for the chamber stuff we're so 100:11 excited to be working with you guys and 100:13 for everyone should just know that the 100:16 city council has been like amazing and 100:18 john mcnally so i just want to do like a 100:20 huge 100:21 shout out um this has been really cool 100:24 um but uh i'm gonna 100:31 oh i think we lost julia 100:41 well yeah i think we lost it well 100:45 sorry are you back you bet i think 100:48 you're back 100:49 oh did you miss me so was i out of here 100:52 yeah you went into a tunnel or something 100:53 you were completely gone 100:55 after the shout out you dropped but 100:57 that's totally cool you can leave it 100:58 there you want to leave it at the shadow 101:02 yeah no i was just gonna say um about 101:05 you know we're talking about like 101:06 you know making money having money so i 101:08 wanted to talk about the ice rink 101:10 and i wanted to know where is the city 101:12 with somebody ask a bunch of questions 101:13 you guys can just answer and i just want 101:15 this like on the record 101:16 um where is the city with the rfp for 101:19 the ice arena 101:20 um i wanted to know why north star rank 101:23 management 101:24 um you know they had made a presentation 101:27 with an 101:28 economic impact study showing the 101:30 benefits of taking over our facility 101:34 and you know i just wanted to 101:37 you know see what's going on there 101:39 because i haven't seen it on the agenda 101:41 um and i mean 101:45 you know i know that ours our rink is 101:47 losing money 101:48 and it's like subsidized by long beach 101:51 taxpayers 101:52 and i think like over 50 of the kids 101:55 that 101:56 that skate there are not from long beach 101:59 so 101:59 if it's losing money and the building 102:01 needs a 102:02 whole lot of money um like 102:09 oh i think we lost there again 102:14 well i'll answer the ice arena rfp um 102:17 was voided and is being reissued um 102:20 the rfp went out the responses we 102:23 received did not match the rfp 102:26 and the responses we received was that 102:28 we would end up paying them 102:30 for the first year um to manage 102:34 and so the rp is being redone um with 102:37 that in mind of them taking it over 100 102:40 completely um and that they would be 102:42 paying us rent 102:44 okay so that sounds much better um 102:48 and i just want to know who's actually 102:50 who's actually going to be 102:52 um writing the rfp 102:56 this is donna i am myself in corp 102:58 council 103:01 okay and do you guys talk to anybody who 103:03 manages 103:04 ice rinks like maybe somebody at 103:05 eisenhower park or you guys just like 103:07 coming up with it on your own 103:09 rfps have a certain um guidelines 103:13 and our rfp is for the management 103:16 and to really to take over the ice arena 103:19 and so we don't need really to we've 103:22 looked at other people's um 103:24 rp's and our own rp for the tennis court 103:27 we're not looking for them to come in to 103:29 give us a service we're looking for them 103:30 to come in 103:31 to take over the building such as we did 103:34 for the magnolia center 103:35 so we're good um the first one that went 103:38 out wasn't 103:39 quite the way we wanted it to be get the 103:41 responses we wanted 103:43 and so that's why we're tweaking it and 103:44 sending it back up 103:48 okay that's awesome and do you guys know 103:50 when you expect to put that out 103:53 early next week awesome thank you so 103:56 much you guys are awesome thank you 103:59 all right take care anyone bye 104:03 anyone else steve nope that's it 104:06 all right well thanks for joining folks 104:09 uh 104:10 we will see you on october 29th for the 104:14 special meeting 104:16 uh you're going to join us otherwise if 104:18 not then remember the next 104:20 regular meeting is not the first tuesday 104:23 in november because that's election day 104:25 uh it will be the 104:26 wednesday the day after the fourth 104:29 so uh so we'll talk to you again on the 104:32 29th 104:33 and have a good night everyone have a 104:35 good night 104:36 get out enjoy uh beyond the beach 104:38 celebration this week